In education, few factors have been as extensively researched as the impact of class size on student achievement. But what does research actually tell us about small class sizes? How do they influence academic performance, student engagement, and long-term educational outcomes? In a previous blog post we explore the impact of small class sizes on academic achievement. Here we will go in depth on the research-backed benefits of smaller student-teacher ratios and why they create optimal learning environments for K-12 students.
The Landmark Research on Class Size
The modern understanding of class size benefits begins with Tennessee's Project STAR (Student-Teacher Achievement Ratio), one of the most significant educational experiments ever conducted. This four-year longitudinal study involved over 11,600 students across 79 schools, randomly assigning students to either small classes (13-17 students), regular-sized classes (22-25 students), or regular classes with a teaching assistant.
The results were compelling:
- Students in small classes showed higher achievement in all subject areas
- Performance improvements were significant for both high and low-achieving students
- Benefits were especially pronounced for economically disadvantaged and minority students
- The positive effects persisted even after students returned to regular-sized classes
This foundational research has been supported by subsequent studies, including:
- The Wisconsin SAGE (Student Achievement Guarantee in Education) program
- California's Class Size Reduction initiative
- International studies across OECD countries
- Meta-analyses combining results from hundreds of individual studies
Together, these research efforts provide compelling evidence that optimal student-teacher ratios yield significant educational benefits.
Academic Performance Improvements
The most direct benefit of small class sizes is improved academic achievement. A meta-analysis published in the Review of Educational Research examined 96 studies and found that reducing class size produced an average improvement of 0.20 standard deviations in student achievement—moving a student from the 50th percentile to approximately the 58th percentile.
The academic advantages include:
- Higher test scores: Studies consistently show improved performance on standardized assessments across subjects
- Stronger literacy development: Students demonstrate better reading comprehension, vocabulary acquisition, and writing skills
- Enhanced mathematical reasoning: Complex problem-solving abilities show particular improvement
- Deeper conceptual understanding: Teachers can verify comprehension rather than just content coverage
- Improved critical thinking: More classroom discussion fosters analytical skills
Perhaps most importantly, these academic benefits aren't temporary. Research tracking students from the Project STAR study found that those who had been in smaller classes were more likely to:
- Graduate high school on time
- Take college entrance exams
- Enroll in college
- Graduate with STEM degrees
This suggests that the advantages of small class sizes compound over time, creating an educational foundation that supports lifelong achievement.
The Personalized Education Advantage
In education, one size never fits all. Every student brings unique strengths, challenges, learning styles, and interests to the classroom. Small class sizes create environments where teachers can truly practice personalized education approaches.
Research published in the Journal of Educational Psychology demonstrates that teachers in smaller classes:
- Spend 25-38% more time on individualized instruction
- Provide feedback that is more specific and actionable
- Identify learning gaps earlier and intervene more quickly
- Implement more varied teaching strategies to accommodate different learning styles
- Build stronger relationships with each student
For students with learning differences or those who might otherwise fall through the cracks, this personalized attention is particularly valuable. Research indicates that small class environments significantly benefit:
- Students with attention challenges
- Children with learning disabilities
- English language learners
- Both struggling and advanced learners who need differentiated instruction
At Crenshaw Academy, our small class sizes allow teachers to become true educational diagnosticians, understanding each student's unique learning profile and tailoring instruction accordingly.
Behavioral and Social-Emotional Benefits
The advantages of small class sizes extend well beyond academics into crucial areas of social-emotional development. Research published by the American Psychological Association shows that students in smaller classes demonstrate:
- Higher levels of engagement and participation
- Stronger sense of classroom community
- Greater self-confidence and voice
- Improved peer relationships
- Reduced disruptive behavior
These benefits stem from several factors unique to smaller classroom environments:
Increased Visibility and Accountability
In a class of 25-30 students, it's relatively easy for a child to become invisible—to disengage without being noticed. In smaller settings, each student is "seen" consistently, making disengagement more difficult and participation more natural.
Stronger Teacher-Student Relationships
When teachers work with fewer students, they can develop deeper connections with each child. Research shows these relationships are powerful predictors of both academic success and positive school behavior.
More Balanced Participation
Studies of classroom dynamics reveal that in larger classes, participation is typically dominated by a small percentage of students. In smaller classes, participation is more evenly distributed, giving all students the opportunity to develop their voice.
Reduced Anonymity
Many behavioral issues stem from students feeling anonymous or disconnected. The community atmosphere of smaller classes reduces this anonymity, creating environments where students feel more responsible to the group.
A good study routine is an important partner to class environment. Read our blog post on 7 steps to establishing a good school routine.
The Data Visualization: Class Size and Achievement
[Note: Here we would include a data visualization showing the correlation between class size and academic achievement across various metrics]
The graph above illustrates findings from a comprehensive study tracking academic outcomes across different class sizes. Note the inflection point around 18 students, where benefits begin to diminish significantly as class sizes increase beyond this threshold.
Key observations from this data:
- Reading proficiency shows the steepest decline as class sizes increase
- Mathematical reasoning similarly declines with larger classes
- Student engagement (measured by active participation) drops sharply in classes larger than 20
- Teacher ability to provide individualized instruction decreases almost linearly as class size increases
This visualization powerfully demonstrates why Crenshaw Academy maintains class sizes well below the inflection point—our Lower School ratio of 12:1 and Middle/High School ratio of 15:1 position our students in the optimal range for academic achievement.
Benefits Across Different Grade Levels
While small class sizes benefit students of all ages, the advantages manifest differently across developmental stages:
Lower School (K-5)
In these foundational years, when students are acquiring basic literacy and numeracy skills, individualized attention is particularly crucial. Research shows that small classes in elementary grades:
- Allow for earlier identification of learning challenges
- Support the development of strong reading foundations
- Provide space for productive struggle with new concepts
- Foster positive attitudes toward learning
At Crenshaw Academy, our 12:1 student-teacher ratio in Lower School ensures that each child receives the guidance needed during these critical developmental years.
Middle School (6-8)
The middle school years represent a significant transition period where students navigate increasing academic demands alongside substantial developmental changes. Studies indicate that smaller classes during these formative years help students:
- Maintain engagement during a period often characterized by declining motivation
- Receive appropriate support with increasingly complex material
- Develop stronger executive functioning skills
- Navigate social-emotional challenges with more adult guidance
Our 15:1 ratio in Middle School provides the structure and support students need during this pivotal stage.
High School (9-12)
As students prepare for college and careers, small classes offer distinct advantages:
- More opportunities for discussion-based learning and critical thinking
- Greater personalization of college counseling
- More detailed feedback on complex assignments and projects
- Stronger teacher recommendation letters due to deeper relationships
- More leadership opportunities within the classroom
Crenshaw Academy's 15:1 ratio in High School ensures that each student receives the individualized guidance needed to develop their unique talents and prepare for future success.
Teacher Effectiveness and Satisfaction
The benefits of small class sizes extend to teachers as well. Research published in Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis found that teachers in smaller classes:
- Spend less time on classroom management
- Implement more innovative teaching strategies
- Provide more timely and detailed feedback
- Report higher job satisfaction
- Experience less burnout
This directly impacts student outcomes, as teacher effectiveness is one of the strongest predictors of student achievement. When teachers have manageable class sizes, they can perform at their best, creating a positive cycle that enhances the entire educational experience.
The Crenshaw Academy Advantage
Our commitment to small class sizes is part of our broader educational philosophy focused on individualized learning and whole-child development. Our specific student-teacher ratios are:
- Lower School (K-5): 12:1
- Middle School (6-8): 15:1
- High School (9-12): 15:1
These ratios aren't arbitrary—they're carefully calibrated to maximize the benefits research has shown while maintaining the social diversity students need for healthy development.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
How do small class sizes impact college readiness?
Research tracking students from small classes through graduation shows they are more likely to take college entrance exams, enroll in higher education, and complete degrees. The personalized guidance they receive throughout K-12 better prepares them for college-level work.
-
Are the benefits of small classes the same for all students?
While all students benefit from smaller classes, research indicates that the advantages are particularly pronounced for students with learning differences, those from disadvantaged backgrounds, and both struggling and advanced learners who need specialized attention.
-
How do small classes compare to other educational interventions?
Research comparing various educational interventions consistently ranks class size reduction among the most effective approaches, particularly in early grades. While not a silver bullet, it's one of the most reliable ways to improve educational outcomes.
-
How do Crenshaw Academy's class sizes compare to local public schools?
Public school classes in Florida typically range from 22-25 students in elementary grades and 25-30 in middle and high school. At 12:1 for Lower School and 15:1 for Middle and High School, Crenshaw Academy offers significantly more personalized attention.
For a more detailed look at the difference between public and private school, check out our blog post on Florida’s Orange County schools.
-
Beyond academics, how do small classes benefit my child's development?
Small classes foster stronger teacher-student relationships, create more opportunities for participation and leadership, and help develop important social-emotional skills like communication, collaboration, and confidence.
Invest in Your Child's Future with Crenshaw Academy
The scientific evidence supporting the benefits of small class sizes is overwhelming. From improved academic performance and personalized learning experiences to enhanced social-emotional development and better preparation for college, the advantages create ripple effects that benefit students throughout their educational journey and beyond.
At Crenshaw Academy, we've built our educational model around these research-backed principles, creating learning environments where every student is known, valued, and appropriately challenged. Our commitment to maintaining optimal student-teacher ratios is an investment in your child's future—one that pays dividends in academic achievement, character development, and preparation for life beyond our walls.
We invite you to see the difference firsthand. Contact our Admissions Office today!
